Bologna Shoah Memorial, Competition entry, April 2015

Yael Reisner in collaboration with:

Abel Maciel, architect / computer engineer.

Nick Cramp, environmental engineer, partner @ Max Fordham.

Ori Gersht, fine art photographer.

Panoramic View of the square as was, paved, and with the two walled air shafts – serving the floor underneath – that had to be kept intact. Any of the square’s existing parts had to stay, as all related to the future high speed train concourse built underneath.

The Shoah Memorial Square’s ground plan, shows us how that looking West is also looking into the railway tracks disappearing into the horizon. The memorial square’s leading concept was built around that given placement.

Morning view of the Bologna Shoah Memorial Square. The marble steps and pavement as seen here, were there already and had to stay. (Part of the given program.) The steel Scroll – Wall is embedded with images – taken from few of Ori Gersht’s work, and from the Holocaust free archives – as well as with lines of referential quotes. The open side of memorial square is further secluded from the main street by seven local Amarena cherry trees, grown in large pots that also serve as public seating.

The back side view created by the ‘Wing’ surface made of blackened steel, seen from the bridge along Via Matteotti, is embedded with a fresco of colourful abstracted flowers we called Blooming – selected stills from Ori Gersht work – On Reflection) – so as not to impose the memorial’s experience on the daily commuters outside of the memorial square. (See about Gersht’s originals further below.)

The video clip submitted to the competition entry, 2015 – Bologna Shoah Memorial.

Sound track: The first 1:10 min. of Ravel’s Kadish, for cello and strings, arrangement by Tognetti, played by Steven Isserlis.

The roof plan shows the memorial square, and at its South-West side the Bologna railway station, across the railway tracks.

Looking from the Bologna Railway Station at the the blooming ‘Wing’ and the ‘Petal’ side of the scroll- wall across the tracks.

This Memorial Square’s back view – would hardly be seen, as public is not allowed into the roof of the future high-speed train’s concourse, yet, it’s a render that show clearly the spatial relationship between the different parts of the memorial square’s open-air enclosure.

The design process

While looking above the site with its numerous rail tracks all the way to the horizon, one cannot help but to bring the association with the railway-tracks that led the deportations throughout Europe by the Nazi’s Reichsbhan and the destination to concentration and death camps. Auschwitz was one of them, and until today these railway tracks are still part of the route to get from Bologna to Auschwitz.

The characteristics of the site’s location led us to the main ideas, while a concept of duality prevails through the design. The embedded artwork – photography – aims at adding to the content and its aesthetics, provoking thoughts and emotions in the beholder.

The views from the memorial square, and the epic photography in it, are intentionally very different from the views of the installation from outside the square, where the passer-by will see different imagery.

We aimed at emphasizing the dual relationship of the memories of the tragic history vs. thoughts of an emphatic future, the horror lived by the victims versus momentarily pleasure drawn from beauty in nature. We designed the dividing surfaces so the sunrise light would enhance certain views and atmosphere in the square vs. others in sunset time; the two extreme conditions along the daily light changes as the sun moves through the sky. Similar light interaction will take place at nighttime with artificial light.

The spatial design was created by two elements: steel ‘scroll-wall’ and a ‘wing’, which together create the design choreography, and the surfaces for the embedded photography.

Two large interactive epic photographs, are embedded – embossed, pigmented, and perforated – on each side of the ‘scroll-wall’ and two other at the ‘wing’, four large frescos, applying new mural techniques, that instead of using paints on plaster manually, it appliess paint on steel surface using digital technologies.

Lines of quotes from Primo Levi’s poetry join in. See further below.

The encoded ‘scroll-wall’ separates diagonally the memorial square into two parts, the opened side (further secluded from the main street by seven local Amarena cherry trees. They are grown in large pots that also serve as public seating). The interior space is enclosed by the encoded ‘wing’- wall, yet, both parts of the square are exposed to the environment’s elements.

The imagery as prepared to be embedded in the front facade of the memorial square. Judith (epic photography by Ori Gersht) along the deportation scenes from the Nazi occupation time, taken from archival material.

Etched lines of quotes, and selected photographs are embedded – embossed, pigmented and perforated – on each side of this Scroll-Wall, as large frescos.

At Sunset – Front view at the Bologna Shoah Memorial square.

View of the the Scroll-Wall’s back side, at the interior – as people enter the open-air enclosed side of the square. A haunting sensation by Judith’s facial features would follow the walker by, due to her perforated faces. That side of the Scroll-Wall is embedded with Gersht’s photograph ‘Floating Petals Black Water’ as its overall fresco. (See originals below.)

At the Wing wall, similarly, though different in content, there are two juxtaposed photographic epics, embedded in it. Its interior surface portrays a scene of shuttered domestic world and great sadness (as part of the enclosed space in the memorial square), while the exterior surface – seen from outside, along the bridge of Via Matteotti and from Bologna station – communicates colorful abstracted flowers. Our intention here is not to impose the memorial’s experience on the daily commuters out of the square, but enhance the surroundings with the message of beauty and hope, adding qualities to the urban context.

Midday’s interior view. Along the fence / shelf (on the right), poetry by Shoah’s survivors is quoted . Amongst, Dan Pagis’ short poem: “written in the sealed railway-car here in this carload I am eve with abel my son if you see my other son cain son of man tell him I“ At the ‘Wing’ – the black wall-ceiling – we can see the fresco we called Shuttered Mirror, which portrays a scene of devastated domestic world. (A collage of 3 selected stills from Gersht’s film On Reflection – see more below. )

The Triptych Fresco we called Shuttered Mirror, portrays a scene of devastated domestic world, is embedded at the Wing wall, on its interior side, at the enclosed part of the memorial square. – (Selected stills from Gersht’s film On Reflection – see more below. )

Interior view at sunset – looking West at the railway-tracks leading one’s sight into the horizon. The visitors at the front seen as ghostly-silhouettes by those who just enter the enclosed-open-air space and walk toward the fence.

Eighteen ‘binoculars openings’ spread along the Scroll-Wall, at the height of people’s eyes, angled towards the view of the railway tracks disappearing into the Horizon.

Looking through one of the eighteen ‘binoculars’ spread along the front facade at the memorial square, angled towards West, the view of the railway tracks disappearing into the Horizon. This image captures Sunset time. (Bologna – Auschwitz route still exist as was during WW2, before and after.)

3D Frescos – created by applying digital technologies – as part of the architectural design

The design pursuit was to explore ways to include imagery in architecture in a fresh way.

The ambition was – after selecting 2-dimensional work by the artist Ori Gersht we collaborate with – to embed the imagery thoughtfully as part of the new three-dimensional frescoes, embedded in the surfaces that create the spatial configuration of the space and place.

This research work started five years ago – 2010 – with the project A Room for London, (see under Projects), an installation we were investigating architecture as a three dimensional canvas to be inhabited and experienced, exploring light, shadows, spatial depth and beauty as the ingredients that might help to stir an emotional experience in the beholder; aspiring to enhance beauty in architecture and induce human wellbeing by architectural experience. The imagery – both its aesthetics and content – was an integral part of the overall deign intention. The artist we collaborated with then, 5 years earlier, was Dee Ferris.

In this project, the selected epic photography is by the fine art photographer Ori Gersht, whose compelling stills and videos, captures beauty and violence in the same work, raising its charged, which is equally augmented by his laborious, perfectionist treatment and focused attention.

Gersht’s photography embedded in the Bologna Shoah Memorial, became three dimensional on the Scroll wall, due to the applied digital multi angle perforation techniques, (perforated, embossed and pigmented), where the epic photography affects differently each side of the wall. Yehudith is observed on both sides of the Scroll-wall, like a haunting ghost, thus, the narrative further interact with the viewer, as he/she walks from one side of the Scroll wall to the other, and vice versa.

Some of Gersht’s narratives portray specific associations of wars and conflicts, often transpired through their depicted locations or refugees, while others are arresting due to a violent fluctuation between figurative and abstract; a whole body of work exceptionally beautiful.

Gersht work embedded in the memorial installation’s metallic surfaces is including:

On the front facade of the ‘scroll wall’: Judith – stills from the video: Yehudith Arnon – Will You Dance For Me? – along archival photos of deportees under the Nazi occupation.
On the inner facade of the ‘scroll-wall‘ – selected from the epic photography Chasing Good Fortune, a still photo entitled Floating Petals-Black Water. But Judith face, re-appears like a ghost, amongst the floating petals.
On each side of the ‘Wing’ wall – stills selected from the video On Reflection – creating two very different frescos; different appearances, different contents. as explained on the text above describing the project; we re-named each of the two fresco: Shuttered Mirror and Blooming.

Thus, we got three narratives: one interacting between the two sides of the Scroll wall, and two others displayed on the Wing wall. Yehudith, Shuttered Mirror and Blooming, in and out of the memorial square, are there to raise different emotional feedbacks, or, associations in the beholder.

Judith; six stills selected from Gersht’s video: Yehudit Arnon – Will You Dance For Me? 2012.

Yehudit Arnon – Will you Dance for Me? is a film the Gersht made and exhibited in 2012, to tell the story of Yehudit Arnon, who as a 19-year-old was imprisoned at Auschwitz where SS guards demanded that she dance at their Christmas party. When Arnon refused, she was forced to stand in the snow as punishment – an event that forged a commitment to dance if she could survive. Arnon went on to a celebrated dance career, and in Gersht’s film she dances one more time and recalls the moment when “for the first time in my life, I was able to say no.” We selected few stills of Judith – in Hebrew Yehudit – from this film, to be added to the Scroll-Wall, the front facade of the Bologna Memorial Square.

Judith, a selected still from Gersht’s film: Yehudit Arnon – Will you Dance for Me?

Judith as in the video’s cover of Yehudit Arnon – Will you Dance for Me?

Judith’s 6 images selected from the epic photography, embedded in between the deportation scenes from the Nazi occupation time, taken from archival material, all along the Scroll wall’s front.

The Scroll Wall frontal view at the Bologna Memorial Square.

The Scroll wall interior view, where Judith’s face re-appear on the background of the still photo by Ori Gersht, entitled <em>Floating Petals-Black Water</em>, selected from his video <em>Chasing Good Fortune</em>.

On Reflection, 2014, by Ori Gersht, and the six stills selected from it to be embedded at both sides of the Wing wall.

As one can see in the next images I chose 6 stills from that On Reflection video photography , three per side of the Wing wall, each becoming a triptych fresco, capturing opposite qualities. One triptych I called Blooming and the other Shuttered Mirror.

Blooming – the large a Triptych Fresco embedded at the Wing wall’s exterior, the view from the outside world, from the street people walk along, the exterior view of the Bologna Memorial Square from the street Via Matteotti, and its bridge part, above the railways tracks.

Shuttered Mirror – the large triptych fresco is embedded on the interior side of the Wing wall, that together with the scroll wall creating the enclosed part of the memorial square, the Shuttered Mirror Triptych is viewed while one is inside the memorial, and it portrays a scene of a devastated domestic world.

As Ori Gersht summed succinctly On Reflection, it is about “the fragility and transience of life, and the fluid relationship between creation and destruction”

Blooming – the large Triptych Fresco is the Wing wall’s exterior, the view of Bologna Memorial Square from the street Via Matteotti, and its bridge part raised above the railways tracks.

The Triptych we called Blooming – three stills selected from Gersht’s film: On Reflection, 2014.

Shuttered Mirror – the large triptych fresco, portrays here a scene of devastated domestic world, is embedded at the Wing wall, on its interior side, at the enclosed part of the memorial square.

The Triptych we called Shuttered Mirror<em>,</em> three stills selected from Gersht’s film: On Reflection, 2014.

Etched Primo Levi’s quotes on the Scroll wall, seen on its right hand side.

The Quotes from Primo Levi’s Poetry etched on the Scroll – Wall

Primo Levi, “The Work” (1983)

Is anything sadder than a train
that leaves when it’s supposed to,
that has only one voice,
only one route?
There’s nothing sadder.

Except perhaps a cart horse,
shut between two shafts
and unable even to look sideways.

Print Levi, “The Survivor” (1984)

Consider whether this is a man,
Who labours in the mud
Who knows no peace
Who fights for a crust of bread
Who dies at a yes or a no.

Yael Reisner Studio’s architectural assistants:

Claudia Tanskanen, Viktor Johansson, Elin Daun, Maja Linse

Under construction.